First human brain implant malfunctioned, Neuralink says ( thehill.com )

The first Neuralink implant in a human malfunctioned after several threads recording neural activity retracted from the brain, the Elon Musk-owned startup revealed Wednesday.

The threads retracted in the weeks following the surgery in late January that placed the Neuralink hardware in 29-year-old Noland Arbaugh’s brain, the company said in a blog post.

This reduced the number of effective electrodes and the ability of Arbaugh, a quadriplegic, to control a computer cursor with his brain.

“In response to this change, we modified the recording algorithm to be more sensitive to neural population signals, improved the techniques to translate these signals into cursor movements, and enhanced the user interface,” Neuralink said in the blog post.

The company said the adjustments resulted in a “rapid and sustained improvement” in bits-per-second, a measure of speed and accuracy of cursor control, surpassing Arbaugh’s initial performance.

While the problem doesn’t appear to pose a risk to Arbaugh’s safety, Neuralink reportedly floated the idea of removing his implant, according to The Wall Street Journal.

The company has also told the Food and Drug Administration that it believes it has a solution for the issue that occurred with Arbaugh’s implant, the Journal reported.

The implant was placed just more than 100 days ago. In the blog post, the company touted Arbaugh’s ability to play online computer games, browse the internet, livestream and use other applications “all by controlling a cursor with his mind.”

Snapz ,

Not the first, first they told people about.

Definitely a closet full of dead bodies over there.

Tattorack ,
@Tattorack@lemmy.world avatar

Dead monkeys and apes, yes. The bodycount in primates for the development of Neuralink isn't... Fun.

ChaoticEntropy ,
@ChaoticEntropy@feddit.uk avatar

Neuralink reportedly floated the idea of removing his implant

This immediately sank when someone pointed out that it would be a PR nightmare, which naturally was more important than patient safety.

0nekoneko7 ,
@0nekoneko7@lemmy.world avatar
profdc9 ,

"Humanity can not progress without heaps" - Hubert Farnsworth

kikutwo ,

And yet we've been implanting Cochlear devices in humans for eons but you can't meld a Musk joke out of that so.

FiniteBanjo ,

The implant failing when the subject's connected tissue died has always been the best possible outcome from this, tbh.

cosmicrookie ,
@cosmicrookie@lemmy.world avatar

I hope Noland has unlimited use because he might risk having to pay a sub to use the implant that they put in his brain

stergro ,

I would never put something in my brain that doesn't at least have a public API documentation. If the company discontinued the product I want to be able to keep using it. Open Source software would be best.

cosmicrookie ,
@cosmicrookie@lemmy.world avatar

'Have you consider running Linux on your neural implant?'

Wiz ,

My question is, does the neutral implant even run Doom?

ZeffSyde ,

"I have a busted old brain from the 80s, what distro would you suggest?"

cosmicrookie ,
@cosmicrookie@lemmy.world avatar

ARC

Allero ,

Open source is the only way for anything that should enter our brains.

Really hope regulations will come to this.

FonsNihilo ,

That's alot easier to type out when you haven't been a quadriplegic for 8 years.

I understand and to a point agree with your points.

But think of it from Nolans perspective. He referred to himself as a waste before he had this implant.
Regardless of how awful Musk is, other people who do care have in Nolans words "Given him purpose" again and has changed his life in only positive ways. If even just for a few months/years he is able to start enjoying life again.

jeffw ,

shocked Pikachu face

FlyingSquid ,
@FlyingSquid@lemmy.world avatar

That's weird. Did he try subscribing to Twitter Blue?

Bluefalcon ,

When did they work? Prior to getting approved in humans they were killing animals at a high rate. To the point where animals were smashing their heads against shit to get the chip out.

Additional veterinary reports show the condition of a female monkey called “Animal 15” during the months leading up to her death in March 2019. Days after her implant surgery, she began to press her head against the floor for no apparent reason; a symptom of pain or infection, the records say. Staff observed that though she was uncomfortable, picking and pulling at her implant until it bled, she would often lie at the foot of her cage and spend time holding hands with her roommate.

I understand testing on animals is tough but this was straight cruelty.

https://www.wired.com/story/elon-musk-pcrm-neuralink-monkey-deaths/

Windex007 ,

It was working for a while for the guy. He was paralyzed from the neck down and he was able to use it to play some lame game like LoL or something.

Bluefalcon ,

Yeah I seen a money kinda play pong on it. It was cool and all but not ripping at your skull cool.

It sucks bc there are real companies developing the tech for an amazing cause. Elon is a dip shit that has no clue on how to run a company and he is actually hurting the research.

curiousPJ ,

You don't even need to be inserting probes to be able to do that...

OCZ had this 'toy' out in 2008.

https://www.newegg.com/p/N82E16826100006

one of the reviews...

Ultra-sensitive, excellent response time. Partial hands free gaming. Cool looking blue LED glow from interface box. This is the future of computer user interface. While designed primarily for FPS games, works exceptionally well with MMOs. Makes Crysis WARHEAD and FarCry 2 a joy to play. As a disabled person, this unit has allowed me to game with all the "normal" folks on the same level.

reddithalation ,

ok but the real interesting stuff like reading hand writing from a paralyzed person imagining writing it and etc are all only for actual electrodes in brains.

rob_t_firefly ,
@rob_t_firefly@lemmy.world avatar

This thing seems to be a later iteration of the Atari Mindlink idea from the 1980s, which presented the illusion of controlling the game with just your thoughts/brain waves/whatever but which was actually just reading the neuromuscular voltage from your forehead (meaning you scrunch your forehead muscles around to control it).

deafboy ,
@deafboy@lemmy.world avatar

I still have this, but suspect it's bricked after I've pressed the "do not press" button on the side. (i'm a filthy button pusher) If anybody has some firmware dumps or at least documentation, I'd appreciate it.

Never managed to use the brainwaves, but it was sensitive to the facial muscle movement. Good enough to play pong.

QuaternionsRock ,

IIRC dude went home and played Civ all night

Sorgan71 ,

[Thread, post or comment was deleted by the author]

  • Loading...
  • BearGun ,

    monkey

    mice

    Can you read?

    andros_rex ,

    When I was in college working in a lab, we were worried about accidentally killing frogs with our equipment because we didn’t have anything filed with the IRB about frogs.

    Everything with Elon bewilders me. I thought this is why we had regulatory agencies.

    Bluefalcon ,

    As we see most regulation agencies are underfunded and undermanned on purpose. I'm sure they are the same.

    JustAnotherRando ,

    This is also why regulatory agencies have been systematically crippled over the last 40 years or so. Damn near every sector has had their regulatory agencies crippled by some combination of reducing authority, underfunding, and understaffing. When the agencies work, the message is "see, we don't need those regulations anymore because we're taking care of things fine on our own," and when they stop working, the message is "we shouldn't be spending money on these agencies! They don't do anything anyway!"

    SparrowRanjitScaur ,

    I'm not defending this, but at least a human electively chooses this procedure and understands why they have a device attached to their head. The monkeys must have had no idea what was going on and just wanted to remove the foreign object.

    Bluefalcon ,

    Very valid point.

    I could argue that the person was mislead, thinking it was successful in animal trials when it wasn't. Plus the mental manipulation on a person that is a paraplegic, having hope this will improve their life is sad. Musk falsely claimed it was safe and no monkeys died due to the implant.

    Maggoty ,

    Ah but you see, that was when they were testing the Worker Attitude Modulation software. (Researchers called it WAM for short and vehemently denied any connection to the word Wham.)

    SharkAttak ,
    @SharkAttak@kbin.social avatar

    "DAddy mUsk laav mme uskahdkadvbgbdg" said the first Neuralink volunteer, Mr. Guinny A. Peeg.

    eestileib ,

    Dude, the guy is quadriplegic. You might take a chance too if you were quadriplegic.

    I've got an peripheral nerve implant that was installed on an experimental basis myself. It was not a fangirl situation, it was a "please please please help me with this pain" situation.

    sucricdrawkcab ,
    @sucricdrawkcab@lemmy.world avatar

    This is the most Omni Consumer Products situation.

    venusaur ,
    @venusaur@lemmy.world avatar

    It’s the first attempt. Failure is gonna happen. This isn’t big news. If they were rolling it out to market that would be different.

    blackbelt352 ,

    Sure failure is gonna happen but neuralink hasn't been particularly successful with all the primates that have been tested with for previous version either.

    LemmynySnicket ,

    This is an article saying it failed in a primate too!

    venusaur ,
    @venusaur@lemmy.world avatar

    Yeah it’s a really difficult problem. The criticism might be that it’s animal cruelty.

    orrk ,

    damn, imagine we did any other medical research with that attitude!

    Larry ,

    What attitude you think people take with other medical research

    orrk ,

    not the silicone valley "keep breaking stuff until it works"

    venusaur ,
    @venusaur@lemmy.world avatar

    Yeah that’s exactly what we’ve been doing in medicine for ever. Are you supposed to just stop trying?

    orrk ,

    so, hate to break it to you, but we in fact don't take that attitude with medical research, anything that had a tendency to kill the pre human control groups generally doesn't keep going, Musk can do this because he is a high profile case, ironically it's how he slips regulations all the time, because there would be backlash from the musk sycophants, but also the general wealthy community who use people like musk as a barometer on how much corruption they can get away with

    venusaur ,
    @venusaur@lemmy.world avatar

    Maybe not now but a lot of what we know in medicine caused animals and people to die despite knowing the risks of experimentation

    orrk ,

    no, not really, that's just a commonly believed myth

    venusaur ,
    @venusaur@lemmy.world avatar

    Wow. Tell that to all the dead people. Whatever helps you sleep at night. Anesthesia. Vaccines. More recently Tuskegee Syphilis Study.

    orrk ,

    ya, nothing was learned in the "Tuskegee Syphilis Study"(see racist torture), Vaccines also didn't one about because we just started injecting people with random shit, and we knew of Anesthesia for a long time, it just wasn't seen as something you use in medicine in more recent history because of religious superstitions in medicine.

    again, Myths, just like the idea that we learned anything from Mengele's horrors

    snownyte ,
    @snownyte@kbin.social avatar

    This is more than enough to turn me off from the idea of neural anything in the brains of humans. Especially if it's all being ran by a fledgling sycophant like Musk.

    Even if it's not drastic, I don't want to know what the worst case scenario would've been.

    Catoblepas ,

    Especially if the extent of it is that it lets you move a mouse. How does that offer any improvement over eye tracking adaptive tech?

    p5yk0t1km1r4ge ,
    @p5yk0t1km1r4ge@lemmy.world avatar

    Idk... I don't like Elon, but this is actually incredibly huge overall. he controlled a computer with his mind. That's amazing for people who could benefit from it. I think it's worth continuing down this path, just to see how it evolves. I'm sure the man knew the risks and still chose to do it, meaning it was worth it to him.

    Voroxpete ,

    This isn't something new to nueralink. Brain-machine interfaces have existed for quite some time. Neuralink is one of a number of companies that are exploring directly implanting these devices rather than using an externally attached (hence, easily removable) interface, but the core thesis of "Brain control computer" isn't any kind of grand leap forward. That's just Musk's marketing.

    p5yk0t1km1r4ge ,
    @p5yk0t1km1r4ge@lemmy.world avatar

    I saw a dude play chess with his mind where otherwise he couldn't. I've never even heard of tech like this, so it's 100% new to me lol

    Catoblepas ,

    Is it because you are unfamiliar with adaptive tech? Eye tracking devices allowing quadriplegic people to interact with computers by looking at them and blinking have been around since at least the mid 00s. Like a decade ago the “mind reading” external tech got cheap enough for simplified toys to be made with it. Implanting it directly into the body is a lot of risk for very little benefit.

    p5yk0t1km1r4ge ,
    @p5yk0t1km1r4ge@lemmy.world avatar

    I just think it's cool, but fuck me right?

    Catoblepas ,

    If you think it’s cool I would hope you think it’s even cooler than you can do this without surgery and that there are literal cheap ass toys you can buy to play with yourself?

    BottleOfAlkahest ,

    Not the person you were responding too but I'd love to learn more about these toys/tech. Are there some key words that would help me search? I'm having some trouble sifting through the search results.

    ramirezmike ,

    I think the most famous one was the star wars jedi force trainer? Some people say it's fake but.. it's like a headset you put on that they claim reads your brain waves and it controls a little fan that switches on and off to make a ball in a tube float

    Catoblepas ,

    They’re usually marketed as “mind control” toys and are operated with a headset that sends a signal to hidden fans that control whatever object it is you’re supposed to be manipulating. Mattel came out with one called Mindflex that’s pretty complicated looking and has a matching price tag, there are some cheaper Star Wars branded ones too. Not sure what brand I tried as it was over a decade ago, but it was a two player game where you tried to move the ball towards the other player along a track.

    curiousPJ ,

    https://www.newegg.com/p/N82E16826100006

    Neural Impulse Actuator or brain-computer interface.

    Soggy ,

    You're presupposing that surgical implants can't be more responsive, intuitive, speedy, or sophisticated than an external device. The eye trackers are very useful but objectively pretty limited. Non-invasive EEG is weak and distorted because there is skull and more brain in the way, so "resolution" is limited.

    If better outcomes are possible by putting electrodes as close to the signal source as can be, why not explore that option?

    Catoblepas ,

    It feels ridiculous that I even need to say this, but you don’t do it because the risk:benefit ratio is lopsided as hell.

    Risks: die from sepsis, have your body reject the implant, the parent company goes out of business and your implant no longer functions (this has happened with several startups), etc

    Benefit: move mouse and click faster

    Soggy ,

    Move mouse and click faster is a big deal when it's the only way you can interact with the world. And it's just a mouse right now, but what about robotic hands? A thought-controlled wheelchair? A tiny bit of agency? Technology is iterative and built on failure, and you want to tell the people trapped in non-functional bodies that it will never get any better?

    Catoblepas ,

    Move mouse and click faster is a big deal when it's the only way you can interact with the world.

    I feel like I’m doing nothing but repeating this: the only way to do that is not with an implant! It’s not implant or nothing!

    And it's just a mouse right now, but what about robotic hands? A thought-controlled wheelchair? A tiny bit of agency? Technology is iterative and built on failure, and you want to tell the people trapped in non-functional bodies that it will never get any better?

    Right now it is not those things, and I’m going to need you to step way the fuck back since your starting premise is that I’m not physically disabled and have no loved ones that are or could benefit from safe, effective adaptive technology. Maybe if it was your cousin or sister you’d have a little more concern about just tossing them into a meat grinder because some tech bro thinks “go fast, break things” is a policy that can and should be translated to human health.

    I do not and will not accept disabled people being sacrificed in the name of progress. They can’t even do this shit in fucking monkeys, bro. Come on.

    HauntedCupcake ,

    It's experimental tech, I wouldn't want to be the Guinea pig either.

    However, if I was quadriplegic and could only use the somewhat limited external tech, and a significant portion of my life was interacting with a computer. Fuck yeah the risk is worth a performance boost. Especially considering this is going to be a lot safer and more powerful when it hits the mass market

    Catoblepas ,

    There is no such thing as an implant or surgery with no risk of sepsis or rejection. The risk may be low in young, healthy patients (ie, not people who are quadriplegic because that leads to many other health concerns with surgeries), but it’s never zero.

    If you’re cool with risking that, okay, that’s your body. Personally I want to live.

    HauntedCupcake ,

    I never said it was, and for some people it will be worth it.

    I'm not going to get Elon's stupid chip, I'm just saying it's not as one sided as you say

    curiousPJ ,

    Just because you never heard of it doesn't mean it hasn't existed...

    released in 2008

    https://www.newegg.com/p/N82E16826100006

    p5yk0t1km1r4ge ,
    @p5yk0t1km1r4ge@lemmy.world avatar

    [I never said it didn't exist but cool I guess.]

    penquin ,

    Hate Elon or love him, this is pretty cool honestly. I hope it succeeds.

    jabathekek ,
    @jabathekek@sopuli.xyz avatar

    Elon is just the face and money man.

    penquin ,

    Understand that, and kudos to all the great minds who made this thing a reality.

    Phegan ,

    Nah this is a pretty dumb idea that is going to go poorly. It's just techobros wishing we lived in a science fiction novel.

    testfactor ,

    Maybe someday, but that's not the point of the tech as it stands. It's accessibility.

    They guy who it failed in (Noland Arbaugh) is a full on quadriplegic. The ability to use a computer in a semi-normal way is absolutely beyond life changing for him.

    penquin ,

    How dare you state anything but "I hate Elon and he's a POS and everything he does is bad". Elon is a garbage human being and I dislike him just as much as the other person, but I'm still going to give credit when it's due. This is a fucking cool idea and will help a lot of people.

    wizardbeard ,

    But those options were available to him without a risky brain implant. There's a large amount of alternative interface methods and tools available for these purposes, they just don't have Musk's marketing budget and they aren't run by someone that owns a newspaper, so they're not well known outside the disabled community.

    We've had wearable (and thus removable and non invasive) neural interfaces for years now that have been able to do mouse control.

    We've had robust eye tracker control since Steven fucking Hawking.

    This is being framed as though this was the only way for this person to have these abilities and options available, and that is patently false.

    testfactor ,

    I'm well aware of the existence of alternatives. But you must agree that what is achievable with an implant far outstrips the current alternatives?

    KuraiWolfGaming ,

    Those alternatives are old tech that has way more limitations than a neural implant.

    Just because there is old tech that SORT OF does this, doesn't mean it can't be improved. That's the same attitude behind "not needing more than 4mb of RAM" back in the day. You can't stop progress all because YOU are fine with the current state of the tech.

    TimeSquirrel , (edited )
    @TimeSquirrel@kbin.social avatar

    Everything's "techbros living in a sci-fi novel", until one day it isn't.

    I'm only 42 and I have seen very incredible advancements made in my lifetime that I never thought would be reality as a child. Handheld mobile communications devices that allow you to talk and share media instantly with anyone on the planet, for instance. That's some literal Star Trek shit. Or the fact we now have the equivalent computing power of all the world's supercomputers in the 80s put together on our desks. Or RNA vaccines, instead of using dead or dying viruses, we can now reprogram the body to make whatever antibodies it needs.

    Lemmeenym ,

    The USB-C set a new benchmark for the popular Apollo 11 comparison. With the release of the USB-C, your phone's charger now is about 563x faster, can store about 75% more commands, and has about 2x the RAM vs the Apollo 11.

    https://www.theverge.com/tldr/2020/2/11/21133119/usb-c-anker-charger-apollo-11-moon-landing-guidance-computer-more-powerful

    KuraiWolfGaming ,

    Based on your reaction, I'd hate to hear your opinion on AI. Let me guess, its corpo data theft and only data theft?

    What about the multitude of FOSS projects that even you could use if you wanted?

    Phegan ,

    You are making a lot of assumptions

    TheBat ,
    @TheBat@lemmy.world avatar

    And when it succeeds, next update will push ads directly in your brain.

    penquin ,

    That made me chuckle. Lol

  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • random
  • [email protected]
  • tech
  • kbinEarth
  • testing
  • interstellar
  • wanderlust
  • All magazines