ex10n ,

Ukraine will continue to fight for what is rightfully theirs. They’ve done an outstanding job so far, and it’s really highlighted the decline of Russian influence on the world stage. Russia is nothing more than a petrodollar fueled aggressor.

lltnskyc ,

Ukraine will continue to fight for what is rightfully theirs

Out of curiosity, how do you define rightfully in that case?
If that “rightfully” is defined as “they owned it before”, how long ago does it go? 5 years? 10 years? 100 years? Or just for as long as it is convenient for you? Should Mongolia try to reconquer all the territories it once owned?
Or is it “rightfully” as in “recognized in international law”/“defined by UN” or something like that? In that case, you surely agree that China should fight for Taiwan, right?

ex10n ,

I define rightfully as internationally recognized sovereign territory, further backed up by the agreements the aggressor made in the past.

lltnskyc ,

So the second option it is.

When is USA planning to send military aid to China to help it reclaim Taiwan that is rightfully theirs?

ex10n ,

When the Taiwanese people democratically declare they want to become part of China. I don’t see the US sending military aid to China as long as their claims to the South China Sea don’t respect international maritime law. I’d also imagine respecting intellectual property rights is a concern, in addition to China’s genocidal actions towards the Uyghurs.

lltnskyc ,

When the Taiwanese people democratically declare they want to become part of China.

Wait what? So if people of a region that is internationally recognized as part of another country declare that they want to be part of another country, you are okay with that?
Then how is Donbass and Crimea doing the same is not okay?
Why is it “rightfully theirs” in case of Ukraine, but not “rightfully theirs” in case of China? What the fuck?

ex10n ,

The Donbass and Crimea are currently occupied by Russia, there’s never been any Ukrainian held election allowing for the secession of this territory. These regions are not self governing entities that can make this determination. With all due respect, you seem a bit dull, so I’ll just leave it at that.

lltnskyc ,

there’s never been any Ukrainian held election

so, there’s been Chinese election allowing for the secession of this territory?

the hypocrisy is mind-blowing :)

hamid ,
@hamid@vegantheoryclub.org avatar

Who is we???

cypherpunks ,
@cypherpunks@lemmy.ml avatar

Who is we???

Perhaps OP is a member of the US congress, trying to figure out what to vote for? 🤪

There is a nice sample of Michael Parenti talking about this kind of use of the word “we” at the beginning of this song. (lyrics here)

mr_satan ,
@mr_satan@monyet.cc avatar

WW3, eventually. The regime won’t stop. The ambition is there to rebuild the USSR. That would mean starting a conflict with NATO and, if I’m lucky, NATO will actually involve.

yogthos ,
@yogthos@lemmy.ml avatar

imagine being so gullible to genuinely believe this nonsense

mr_satan ,
@mr_satan@monyet.cc avatar

Which part is gullible?
That current Russian regime won’t stop? It’s not like it would be a first time for them to invade another country.
Or did you mean NATO involvement? Who knows… I’d like to believe that they would involve, but I’m not guaranteed.

yogthos ,
@yogthos@lemmy.ml avatar

Sure buddy, the largest country in the world with sparse aging population is on a mission to conquer Europe. 🤡

Woozythebear ,

So Putin who has said many of times how much he hates the USSR is trying to reform it? The fuck are you talking about? You’re just a war monger

captainlezbian ,

He wants the empire not the communism

mr_satan ,
@mr_satan@monyet.cc avatar

He also said there’s no war just a special military operation, but here we are.

kusukasaka281 ,

Then there will be more aid to israel.

bennieandthez ,
@bennieandthez@lemmygrad.ml avatar

They will lose either way, but they’d have less debts to paid and less things to rebuild.

Also Ukraine will benefit from denazification, the ultranationalism pushed by the ukranian nationalists only brings zero-sum situations for Ukraine and its neighbours not just Russia.

lud ,

Instance checks out.

Fuck off Putin

bennieandthez ,
@bennieandthez@lemmygrad.ml avatar

Surely the Ukranian people had much control on the decisions made by the puppet goverment after the 2014 coup 😂 surely the Ukranian people must’ve enjoyed the increase in military budget, that surely increased their living standards data.worldbank.org/indicator/MS.MIL.XPND.ZS?end=2…

highalectical ,
@highalectical@lemmygrad.ml avatar

putin smug problem, liberal?

yogthos ,
@yogthos@lemmy.ml avatar

Exact same thing that will happen if you pass aid to Ukraine, except less people will die.

lud ,

I think it’s up to Ukraine to decide if they want to defend themselves or not and they have obviously selected defense.

Russia is the aggressor and is solely responsible for the deaths in this case.

yogthos ,
@yogthos@lemmy.ml avatar

Western backed regime in Ukraine is literally kidnapping people off the streets and forcing them into fighting. Even mainstream western media admits this nytimes.com/…/ukraine-military-recruitment.html

lud ,

Yes very unfortunate but Russia is no better.

yogthos ,
@yogthos@lemmy.ml avatar

That’s pure nonsense given that this is not happening in Russia. Maybe stop guzzling propaganda and start engaging with reality.

lud ,

nytimes.com/…/russia-convicts-soldiers-ukraine.ht…

But the worst thing about Russia is obviously that they started the war and are killing Ukrainians in the tens of thousands and are destroying the country for generations to come.

You should stop blindly believing everything the Russians say and especially spreading their propaganda.

yogthos ,
@yogthos@lemmy.ml avatar

Comparing convicts to nabbing people off the street exposes your intellectual dishonesty. However, the fact is that Russia isn’t even doing that anymore. They literally have people volunteering. You should follow your own advice and stop projecting. Everything I’ve been saying about this conflict for the past two years is becoming increasingly obviously true. Meanwhile, people who have been peddling western propaganda are looking like clowns at this point. The fact that you lack any capacity for self reflection is just amazing.

Maybe ask yourself how is it that Russia isn’t collapsing like you were promised, that Russian economy is outperforming the west, that Russian army is becoming stronger than NATO. This all being openly discussed by the same western media that said all those things would happen. Yet, here you are bleating about Russian propaganda.

lud ,

None of that really matters when Russia is the one that is invading a foreign country and killing its citizens. Funny how all of you keep ignoring that or you just recite the Russian government propaganda.

yogthos ,
@yogthos@lemmy.ml avatar

It matters a whole lot actually because this a proxy war between NATO and Russia. NATO is just as responsible for what’s happening, and in fact we now know that it was the west that intervened to stop negotiations in Istanbul that could’ve stopped the war back in 2022. Bleating about Russian propaganda isn’t going to change the facts of the situation.

What I recite is what mainstream western media openly says now, and if you claim that’s Russian propaganda then you’re exposing yourself as a troll.

lud ,

Russia invaded Ukraine. NATO didn’t.

yogthos ,
@yogthos@lemmy.ml avatar

This is an infantile understanding of the situation. NATO expansion was the cause of the invasion as even Stoltenberg has now admitted publicly.

lud ,

Why did the countries choose to join NATO? Maybe it was because Russia is a threat. A fact that was later proved by the invasion of Ukraine which actually made more countries join NATO.

yogthos ,
@yogthos@lemmy.ml avatar

Because US has a massive propaganda machine and literally overthrows governments that aren’t compliant. Entire books have been written on this subject, and yet here you are spewing ignorant drivel smugly.

lud ,

Russia invaded Ukraine. The USA didn’t. They have also done terrible things but we are discussing the invasion of Ukraine now.

Just because the USA has overthrown governments doesn’t give Russia any right to invade Ukraine many years later.

here you are spewing ignorant drivel smugly.

Ditto. A country which is so afraid of freedoms and rights can’t be trusted. Any reasonable country allows journalists to live.

yogthos ,
@yogthos@lemmy.ml avatar

USA literally published a paper on how they want to goad Russia into a war in Ukraine with the goal of extending Russia www.rand.org/pubs/research_reports/RR3063.html

USA ran a coup in Ukraine that overthrew a democratically elected government to put a far right regime in place that then committed atrocities against people of Donbas since 2014. I lovew how you ignore all that since it doesn’t fit your infantile narrative.

Ditto. A country which is so afraid of freedoms and rights can’t be trusted. Any reasonable country allows journalists to live.

I never said I trust the US regime or their media.

lud ,

How can’t you understand that Russia literally invaded and started a war. That is objectively way worse than what anyone else did.

I love how all you idiots on lemmygrad, hexbear and .ml constantly show how stupid you all are.

I never said I trust the US regime or their media.

I was obviously referring to Russia which has some of the worst press freedoms in the world. I obviously know you don’t trust the USA media (unless they report something that helps your pro russian propaganda of course).

You only trust the Russian government blindly.

yogthos ,
@yogthos@lemmy.ml avatar

[Thread, post or comment was deleted by the moderator]

  • Loading...
  • lud ,

    Russia intervened in 2014 by for example occupying Crimea.

    yogthos ,
    @yogthos@lemmy.ml avatar

    Oh jeez you’re right, I wonder what that was in response to.

    mukt ,
    @mukt@lemmy.ml avatar

    Why did the countries choose to join NATO?
    Maybe it was because Russia is a threat. A fact that was later proved by the invasion of Ukraine which actually made more countries join NATO.

    If we are making hypothesis, USA bullying smaller countries into joining its own gang is much more probable. After all, it is not disputed that USA has been bullying everyone into forcing sanctions against Russia and only big countries like India and Germany have been able take a stand against American bullying.

    lud ,

    My country joined because of Russia and their invasion of Ukraine not because of the USA.

    mukt ,
    @mukt@lemmy.ml avatar

    Whatever makes you feel better. I am done here. I’ll leave some reading material for you though.

    If you haven’t read actual Russian propaganda so far, I’d highly recommend reading the entire Big Serge’s Substack for a rather informed take from perspective of a Russian in USA.

    Enjoy these long reads with good tea.

    lud ,

    I suggest you grow up.

    mukt ,
    @mukt@lemmy.ml avatar

    Ok. Mama.

    mukt ,
    @mukt@lemmy.ml avatar

    30% population of pre-SMO Ukraine was Russian. And a dicriminated minority. Who invaded whom is a matter of how well versed you are with one side of propaganda and how ignorant of the other.

    lud ,

    Please provide evidence to the contrary then.

    It’s extremely easy to find tons of images of russian troops invading Ukraine.

    I have yet to find any images of Ukraine invading Russia.

    mukt ,
    @mukt@lemmy.ml avatar

    Russian side of propaganda is not too difficult to find, even in the English world. Why don’t you do a google search by yourself and list 10 results of what you found ?

    lud ,

    Why would I go out of my way to prove your point? Why would I ever look for Russian propaganda?

    Your argument is yours to prove not mine.

    mukt ,
    @mukt@lemmy.ml avatar

    You haven’t substantiated your own assertion about NATO not invading Russia. It is your point at stake. I simply pointed you to an undeniable fact that torpedos your assertion, and pointed you to relevant literature, which you are refusing to look into.

    Your point stands logically punctured. Feel free to flee.

    lud ,

    Lol. You can’t just say without sources that NATO invaded Russia and then get mad when I deny it. That’s like the people that claim that the earth is flat say that everyone else has to prove otherwise.

    Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, and you have none.

    mukt ,
    @mukt@lemmy.ml avatar

    Flat eathers actually give what they think is evidenxe fir their claims.
    Looks like you haven’t actually read much there either.

    lud ,

    Lol, says the dude that gives no evidence.

    mukt ,
    @mukt@lemmy.ml avatar

    Says the guy who needs no evidence for his beliefs.

    lud ,

    Wow comeback 😲

    mukt ,
    @mukt@lemmy.ml avatar

    Russia doesn’t share your assumption that it is a foreign country. That assumption is rather limited to English propaganda, and Russia hasn’t invested much resources in countering institutional propaganda in the English world - they don’t need to fight a pointless war at that front.

    lud ,

    I don’t care what Russia thinks. Pretty much the entire world agrees that Ukraine is a foreign country and if it weren’t I wonder why it let Ukraine have its own government and so on.

    bennieandthez ,
    @bennieandthez@lemmygrad.ml avatar

    Surely the Ukranian people had much control on the decisions made by the puppet goverment after the 2014 coup 😂 surely the Ukranian people must’ve enjoyed the increase in military budget, that surely increased their living standards data.worldbank.org/indicator/MS.MIL.XPND.ZS?end=2…

    bradorsomething ,

    They didn’t, and stop calling me Shirley.

    lud ,

    What? A country increases its military spending after a part of the country gets annexed by Russia‽ Who could have guessed.

    OrnluWolfjarl ,

    So the 15000 civilian deaths caused by Ukraine bombing its own provinces before Russia intervened, the constant efforts by Russia to resolve the issue diplomatically, the naked refusal of the West to even engage with Russia, the West openly backing a fascist coup in Ukraine, and then arming it with the explicit dictate of provoking Russia, the West pressuring Ukraine to not accept the generous settlement offered by Russia in May after the war started, all that doesn’t count?

    mukt ,
    @mukt@lemmy.ml avatar

    Ukraine decided. To vote a comedian to a serious office.
    They were probably hoping for a comedy, but what they have got is a tragedy.

    Russia is doing what it had promised to do in its earlier agreements with Ukraine. It can’t be blamed if the electorate in another country doesn’t take things seriously.

    lud ,

    Please provide sources for the agreement that says “please invade me and kill lots of our citizens if we ever elect a former comedian as a president”

    mukt ,
    @mukt@lemmy.ml avatar

    Maybe find a source for the quoted text first.

    lud ,

    It was obviously a joke dude. You Russians have no humor.

    But seriously provide a source for the alleged agreement you said existed.

    mukt ,
    @mukt@lemmy.ml avatar

    Sigh… I am no Russian.
    Just someome who reads both sides of propaganda.

    lud ,

    Sure…

    ex10n ,

    Russia falling on its face, as an aggressor in this invasion, to a country ran by a comedian really helps to put context to Russia’s decline. They basically shot themselves in the foot and if there weren’t lives being lost, it’d be fairly comedic.

    mukt ,
    @mukt@lemmy.ml avatar

    The only comedy is that Russia is falling on its face since 26 months now.

    lltnskyc ,

    Zelensky will finally have to negotiate and end the war (that is, if he wouldn’t get overthrown/killed before that), and millions of Ukrainians will finally get to live without fear of them/their husbands/fathers/etc. getting kidnapped on the streets and being sent to army to die or get permanently wounded.

    Routhinator ,
    @Routhinator@startrek.website avatar

    Found the Russian loyalist apparently.

    yogthos ,
    @yogthos@lemmy.ml avatar

    what an amazing counterargument you’ve mustered there

    lltnskyc ,

    So, wanting my family that is trapped in Ukraine to stay alive makes me a Russian loyalist? How so?

    Nomecks ,

    Russia has typically been great to non-ethnic Russians, right?

    lltnskyc ,

    Ukrainians in Crimea and other annexed territories [that are not close to the front lines] have more or less normal life now. They can continue living where they live, or they can at any moment return to Ukraine, nobody is holding them hostage, they are free!
    On the other hand, Ukrainians who failed to escape Ukraine don’t really have a choice other live in fear that today might be the day they (or their family) get kidnapped and sent to the army, or try to escape and get caught by “heroes” of the border patrol who carefully watch that nobody escape the meat grinder (unless they give them a hefty bribe).

    sunbeam60 ,

    “They are free!”

    Provided you don’t criticise Russia’s actions, the regime, try to change anything or raise an issue about any oligarch stealing.

    That’s not freedom.

    lltnskyc ,

    That’s not freedom.

    Have you read what I’ve written? Let me quote myself again:

    Ukrainians who failed to escape Ukraine don’t really have a choice other live in fear that today might be the day they (or their family) get kidnapped and sent to the army, or try to escape and get caught by “heroes” of the border patrol who carefully watch that nobody escape the meat grinder (unless they give them a hefty bribe).

    You’re absolutely right about Russia having problems you’ve described, I’ve never said Russia is a good place to live (except when comparing to current situation in Ukraine) but in Ukraine people are getting kidnapped and sent to die! Literally! How can you even compare those two things?
    If you don’t like what happens in Russia - you can just leave. You are not a hostage! If you like Ukraine so much - go buy a ticket and join army as a volunteer.
    If you don’t like what happens in Ukraine - you can’t do anything! You are not allowed to leave country, don’t even dream about going to Russia! You can’t even come close to a border! You are treated worse than a street dog! You can only try to hide from the government until it gets overthrown or until somehow the war ends.

    sunbeam60 , (edited )

    If you’re conscripted you’re not kidnapped.

    I’ve been conscripted myself. I did my years in the army. They were not a kidnapping.

    If you resist a conscription done by a democratic, legal government of the country you’re living in, you’re not kidnapped; you’re caught. Call a spade a spade.

    lltnskyc ,

    You naming it conscription instead of kidnapping doesn’t mean it’s not kidnapping. Talk about calling spade a spade…

    Weslee ,

    Pretty sure Russia “kidnaps” (conscripts) a hell of alot more than Ukraine does.

    Russia also beating Ukrainians in the occupied territories, forcing them to become Russian citizens, and then either forcing them into fighting against their own country or ship them off to some labour camp never too be seen again.

    Do you think they are “free” to leave Russia?

    lltnskyc , (edited )

    Pretty sure Russia “kidnaps” (conscripts) a hell of alot more than Ukraine does.

    Russia does have conscription which is totally immoral and wrong as well, but it does not kidnap people into army (or at least does not do that on a scale nearly close to Ukraine).
    Ukraine literally does kidnapping (catching people on the streets, running after them and using force to put them into vans/etc. Some people manage to self-defend with pepper-sprays, or outrun them or sometimes got protected by a crowd of people, but those are the lucky ones).
    Source: uadraftmuseum.ch, and if you search comments on this post you’ll see another guy posting a link to nytimes (a western media!) talking about the same, but it is paywalled and I cannot read it so I won’t repost it.

    Russia also beating Ukrainians in the occupied territories

    Yes. Note how I never said that Russia are the good guys. There are no good guys, everybody commits warcrimes (Including Ukraine, USA, and all the other countries that are currently considered good guys by the mainstream media). I am just saying that people in Russia (including Ukrainians on occupied territories) have unimaginably more freedom than people in Ukraine.

    forcing them to become Russian citizens

    I included a source for my claims, surely you have a source for your claims? There was another article here on lemmy about nuclear power plant where “everything is going terrible right now, because only the intelligent Ukrainians know how to operate it, and they are not allowed to work on it because they have refused to accept Russian citizenship”. So which one is it, are they forced to become Russian citizens or not?

    either forcing them into fighting against their own country or ship them off to some labour camp never too be seen again.

    Which is so much different from what Ukraine does, right? Or in case of Ukraine it’s all alright because the west supports it, but in case of Russia it’s barbaric?
    Btw, any source on “ship them off to some labour camp never too be seen”? I suspect you might have confused history of USSR with current events.

    Do you think they are “free” to leave Russia?

    Literally, yes. Some of my family (but unfortunately not everyone, because lately escaping this west-supported mass-prison is almost impossible) managed to escape Ukraine by going to occupied territories, and from there to Russia itself, and then they just left Russia and went wherever they wanted. (Obviously nobody here would believe that I’m actually Ukrainian, because as we all know all Ukrainians are happy to die in the meat grinder while screaming “for the glory of Zelensky, my only master”, and those who want their family and friends to stay alive are Russian bots, so you can replace “my family” with “many Ukrainians” if that will make it easier for you to read).
    Do you have any sources claiming otherwise?

    OrnluWolfjarl ,

    That’s a lot of assumptions to make an argument.

    OrnluWolfjarl ,

    Ok, so Zelensky has banned opposition parties, arrested political opponents. And furthermore he cancelled elections that were supposed to happen next month. Will you be condemning Ukrainian conscription then, since the government will neither be democratic or legally elected?

    highalectical ,
    @highalectical@lemmygrad.ml avatar

    Calling it kidnapping is calling a spade a spade you dumb fuck. Here’s another spade you libcuck imperialist rats refuse to call a spade: UKKKraine is a nazi controlled state dancing on the puppet strings of the Empire of Lies - the United $$naKKKes of AmeriKKKa. Mark my words - the oppressed nations shall destroy the west, ending its 5 century reign of terror.

    ikidd ,
    @ikidd@lemmy.world avatar

    Jesus, the stupid fucking clowns on this website make me sad. Appeasement never ends and anyone that thinks it does should share the fate of the poor bastards that they’re pushing into the arms of a madman.

    lltnskyc ,

    stupid fucking clowns

    Ad Hominem

    sunbeam60 ,

    But sometimes you gotta call a spade a spade. If you think Putin will finish after a victory in Ukraine you must never have opened a history book in your life.

    lltnskyc ,

    So if you hate Putin so much - then why don’t you go and fight him yourself? Why do you want millions of Ukrainians to die instead of you, for your goals? How can you think you have a moral high ground supporting a genocide?

    sunbeam60 ,

    That has got to be the dumbest thing I’ve read in a while.

    lltnskyc ,

    Would you like to explain what’s exactly dumb about that?

    MeowZedong ,
    @MeowZedong@lemmygrad.ml avatar

    Ad hominem against themselves…

    waka ,

    Ukraine alone won’t be the cause for a dystopian scenario with Russia as the world government, but I don’t like where it would be going if Ukraine fell. Russia surely wouldn’t stop afterwards. I’d rather see a world where trade connects people than a world where governments forcefully connect people via ideologies. The latter never worked out for anyone.

    yogthos ,
    @yogthos@lemmy.ml avatar

    It’s incredible how western propagandists managed to convince people that world’s biggest country with low aging population is on a mission of territorial conquest.

    GreyEyedGhost ,

    Putin himself likened himself to Peter the Great, speaking of returning and strengthening once-held territories. Unless you agree with his premise that this land was always Russia, despite the current rulers and wishes of the populations living there, territorial expansion is the only conclusion to his statements.

    yogthos ,
    @yogthos@lemmy.ml avatar

    Maybe should read what Putin actually said instead of linking to a US propaganda outlet.

    GreyEyedGhost ,

    Well, if you have a more accurate source, please share.

    I remember a number of news outlets in various western countries quoting Putin talking about rebuilding the Russian empire, but I didn’t bother to save links because I didn’t think people would glibly deny his stated intentions a couple years later.

    yogthos ,
    @yogthos@lemmy.ml avatar

    Go to the official Russian transcript that’s published maybe? I love how you keep acting like the only source that exists is out of context quotes in western media.

    GreyEyedGhost ,

    Cool, post a link and I’ll run it through a translator.

    yogthos ,
    @yogthos@lemmy.ml avatar

    You’re the one who brought this up, so why don’t you go look up the whole quote. It’ll be a good experience for you to learn how to actually read information from primary sources. You don’t even have to run it through a translator because Russia publishes official transcripts in english.

    Sethayy ,

    Cause even then you’ll probably just whine and complain their translator isnt accurate enough or something.

    They’ve already provided a lot more info than you just saying ‘ackshully’ which carries a credibility of 0, even if their sources were shit (not saying they are or aren’t)

    yogthos ,
    @yogthos@lemmy.ml avatar

    Sure that’s what it is

    GreyEyedGhost ,

    I made my points and defended them with sources that can be verified or dismissed. You make your points, and lay the onus on others to prove you right or wrong, while dismissing any and all support they may provide. To quote Hitcheson’s Razor, “what can be asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence.” Or to put it in a more modern way, “put up or shut up.”

    yogthos ,
    @yogthos@lemmy.ml avatar

    You used so many words to say that you refuse to actually find and read the primary source that your whole argument is premised on. The fact that you don’t see a problem with that says everything I need to know.

    GreyEyedGhost ,

    Put up or shut up.

    yogthos ,
    @yogthos@lemmy.ml avatar

    You made the claim little buddy, so go and find the primary source for your claim.

    InternetUser2012 ,

    At this point, you’re just a troll and love the taste of Putin’s dick, clown.

    MeowZedong ,
    @MeowZedong@lemmygrad.ml avatar

    Fuckin gottem! Good point with that Putin’s dick line. I bet he’ll totally rethink everything he said now.

    You fucking debate pervert loser. Go read a book.

    yogthos ,
    @yogthos@lemmy.ml avatar

    I’d be really insulted if I had a shred of respect for your opinion.

    InternetUser2012 ,

    Ah yes, troll it is, thank you for the confirmation komrade.

    Omega_Haxors , (edited )

    The war will stop, simply put. NATO has been artificially extending this war for far longer than it should have been given the circumstances.

    Ukraine had a chance to do peace talks but they blew it trying to have their cake and fuck it too, so now they’re going to lose it all.

    EDIT: Oh sorry, the way I put it was turning off a lot of people. Let me rephrase that. Ukraine will see that they are all alone in this fight because the US is too busy doing genocide in the middle east and they will tap into their superior Nordic genetics and unlock their superpowers. They will fly through the air and launch the crippled forces of russian ork war crimes into the stratosphere, the remaining will bow down and admit that nazism is the superior form of government as Russia is forced to finally admit they were losing. In short: they will win by a landslide just like all of the western media has been saying all along. EDIT2: WHAT!? I said Ukraine was going to win, what more do you want from me?? EDIT3: I can’t believe that worked.

    shinigamiookamiryuu ,

    I do still have at least a little hope Ukraine is going to win. A territory does not typically successfully invade another territory a second time. However, I continue to be outspoken for Ukraine. Without aid, Ukraine will probably do what Chechnya is doing and just resort to dirtier tactics, which I’m glad Ukraine is not doing yet.

    Aria ,

    What about that time they sneaked bombs onto a civilian lorry and blew him up with his family as he was crossing the bridge out of Crimea?

    shinigamiookamiryuu ,

    Unless my memory is just bad, this is the first I heard about that, though even that is much less dirty than the worst done by Chechnya (or Russia), whose national values I wonder about at this point.

    Aria ,
    Hjalamanger ,
    @Hjalamanger@feddit.nu avatar

    Please define “we”. This is a international community so you can’t assume that everyone lives in the same country as you.

    pumpkinseedoil ,

    I’ll assume they mean the countries that currently support Ukraine

    lemmylem OP ,

    Well, who else in the world has been trying to a pass multibillion dollar aid package to Ukraine for the past couple months? The aid is about to get voted on this weekend.

    DavidDoesLemmy ,
    @DavidDoesLemmy@aussie.zone avatar

    I don’t follow every countries politics and what bills they’re trying to pass. I barely keep track of my own country’s stuff.

    lemmylem OP ,

    You right, my bad bro

    B0rax ,

    Well, I don’t know, but multiple countries in the EU have been debating and passing multibillion dollar packages to Ukraine.

    nawordar ,

    The Default Country, I guess

    Goun ,

    The country that’s not part of the rest of the world

    Ultragigagigantic ,
    @Ultragigagigantic@lemmy.world avatar
    Goun ,

    Lol weren’t they claiming they support the two state solution literally a couple of days ago?

    PatMustard ,

    We’re on a lemmy.ml community, so Mali I guess

    Harbinger01173430 ,

    Rome?

    supercriticalcheese ,

    Yes both Western and Eastern Roman empire!

    federalreverse ,

    Either the EU manages to step in and largely fill the gap, or Ukraine will have to give in. Russia can then ingest Ukraine, continue to seed political distrust in Western countries and then potentially start another war in Europe a few years later.

    Alternatively, the NATO/EU/US may decide to become directly involved in the war in Ukraine to avoid a further destabilization of Europe. In that case, Russia can be beat, although I’d expect Russians to be more motivated to go into war.

    I’m not sure whether the way the war against Ukraine plays out has too much influence on whether China decides that it needs to start a war against Taiwan though.

    Diabolo96 ,

    Why do people talks so easily about US starting war with Russia? They each have thousands of nukes and if it devolves into nuclear war then earth is fucked beyond repair for at least a few centuries. This is not WW2 anymore, a war doesn’t mean dropping with a bunch of soldiers on a beach, it means an apocalyptic destruction of earth.

    assembly ,

    That is true but at the same time, a line has to be drawn somewhere. If we just let Russia win because they have nukes, there is nothing to stop them from invading and absorbing other neighbors. We can’t let the threat of nukes keep us from doing anything and allowing for Russia and China to just invade anywhere they want.

    Diabolo96 , (edited )

    No earth is better ? Got it! Let the great reset begins!

    We haven’t even colonized a single other planet and we depleted earth ressources pretty bad,so if it’s a reset, it will be a complete hard reset that bricks earth save file forever. No more technological evolution for any future inhabitants ! The great filter might actually be the answer to the Fermi paradox after all.

    We can’t let the threat of nukes keep us from doing anything and allowing for Russia and China to just invade anywhere they want.

    This part gave me a nervous laugh. ‘Only us are allowed to invade anywhere we want, and if anyone else does it we’re ready to hard reset earth because we want the exclusivity rights!’

    Vendetta9076 ,
    @Vendetta9076@sh.itjust.works avatar

    Cope and seethe. Ukraine deserves to keep its independence and hopefully America continued to support it. Russia isn’t going to use their nukes and every time they threaten it, fewer and fewer people get scared each time. Also American isn’t going to go to war with Russia, they’re just going to keep sending mothballed armour that destroys the Russian stuff.

    Diabolo96 , (edited )

    Get off your high horses. I know Ukraine is a very sensitive subject for some but I didn’t mention anything about it. We’re fucking talking about not escalating it into nuclear war here. You know Ukraine, and no other country for that matter, would exists after a nuclear holocaust,right ?

    Lastly, I am against colonization and invasion of any kind.

    Vendetta9076 ,
    @Vendetta9076@sh.itjust.works avatar

    This post is about Ukraine mate.

    Second, there will be no nuclear war escalation so calm down.

    Cope and seethe.

    Diabolo96 ,

    This post is about Ukraine mate.

    And the comments I was answering to was talking about nato/us/eu starting a war with Russia. You should be less oversensitive.

    Second, there will be no nuclear war escalation so calm down.

    Yep, The rest of the world would greatly appreciate it.

    Cope and seethe.

    I geuss you didn’t read the last part of my comment then.

    yogthos ,
    @yogthos@lemmy.ml avatar

    Given that Ukraine is losing so obviously that even western media admits it now, it’s pretty clear that you’re the one doing all the coping and seething here.

    archomrade ,

    We can’t let the threat of nukes keep us from doing anything and allowing for Russia and China to just invade anywhere they want.

    I’m sorry, but yes-we-fucking-can.

    Jesus, people here are so fucking blood thirsty that they’re willing to entertain nuclear-fucking-holocaust just to ‘draw a line in the sand’

    Friendly reminder that the US has already been ‘invading anywhere they want’ - I sure am glad the baddies aren’t as eager as the good guys are to glass half the planet.

    assembly ,

    No one here is bloodthirsty other than the country that invaded Ukraine and now wants to wipe out its people. We are just supposed to sit back and let it happen and let the Russians just keep picking random countries to destroy? No one is advocating for use of weapons of mass destruction but they are advocating for the defense of an independent country attempting to defend itself.

    archomrade ,

    The existence of nukes takes direct military intervention off the table, full stop. Diplomacy is the only way unless a nuclear exchange is acceptable to you.

    The US is so privileged that they don’t realize that “just sit back and let it happen” is how the rest of the world has had to deal with them for the last 80 years, and now it’s unconscionable to think they have to ‘let it happen’ with a foreign adversary themselves

    I think the world would be better if every country had nukes and countries like Russia, Israel, and the US couldn’t simply steamroll every other country standing in their way.

    Diabolo96 , (edited )

    You’re making too much sense for their patriotic propaganda riddled brains. During the cold war, the media made the population fear the enemy and it’s nukes. Nowadays, they instead turned it into making a complete joke of Russia , even making fun of their nukes. So, no wonder the US population think it’s ok to start a war with them despite the thousands of nukes at their disposal. They think it’ll be as easy as invading yet another poor middle eastern country.

    intensely_human ,

    The alternative to this “line in the sand” is the eventual destruction of all things beautiful and good at the hands of the world’s most evil people.

    Stop being naive.

    archomrade ,

    The alternative to this “line in the sand” is the eventual destruction of all things beautiful and good at the hands of the world’s most evil people.

    Lmao who’s being naive?

    jumjummy ,

    What an idiotic take on this. Yes we can let China and Russia take what they want? Tell me you’re a tabkiensithout telling me you’re one.

    What country do you live in, and how ok would you be with being annexed into Russia.

    archomrade ,

    It’s not a matter of being ok with another country abusing their neighbors, nor is it about ‘letting them do what they want’, it’s about acknowledging the mutually assured destruction established during the cold war and having to reckon with the fact that there are other nations with the ability to end civilization that have other ambitions than you.

    Leftists get mocked a lot about their pie-in-the-sky economic goals, but at least they have an intimate understanding of international conflict and the reality of oppositional superpowers. Unlike sheltered american adolescents who’ve never left their country for more than a week and have been assured their entire life that the US is the most powerful and moral nation on earth.

    And that’s to say nothing about the fact that america is the antagonist to most other nations on the planet.

    bennieandthez ,
    @bennieandthez@lemmygrad.ml avatar

    The global majority prefers multipolarity than the US hegemony, the US has spent decades destabilizing our countries while China has developed win-win respectful relationships.

    The US has military bases in countries that you do not know they exist, spends more in war than the redt of the world combined and has killed exponentially more people than anyone else.

    Here is how the good ol’ US of A sees our countries: youtu.be/fCZLWWD1okg?si=cFZPxH-4U-GkqOF2, just a “region” filled with “rare earth minerals”.

    bennieandthez ,
    @bennieandthez@lemmygrad.ml avatar

    Only the US and Europe has the unalienable right to invade and bomb anywhere they want.

    highalectical ,
    @highalectical@lemmygrad.ml avatar

    Inb4 muhwuttabowtism

    froh42 ,

    I live in Germany, was a teenager in the 80s. We would have been ground zero then, and would be ground zero now.

    I’ve already spent all the fear of nuclear war in the 80s. I am just not able to fear nuclear war now, anymore. The fear just dulls after nearly half a century.

    The choice is to let a madman bring war to one country after another or to stop it - with the cost that stopping has a miniscule chance of me getting vaporized.

    But doing nothing will keep the risk of nuclear war for another 50 years. It has to be stopped now, appeasement never did anything good.

    yogthos ,
    @yogthos@lemmy.ml avatar

    All the west has accomplished so far is to ensure that more Ukraine is destroyed, and it’s obvious to anybody with a functioning brain that there is no chance of Ukraine winning at this point. The best chance Ukraine had was last summer during the fabled offensive that failed miserably. Ukraine is never going to be in as good position going forward. So the actual choice is to ensure more people keep dying or to negotiate with Russia. Incredible that after two years westerners still can’t get this through their skulls.

    Woozythebear ,

    Bro we are on the brink of nuclear war with Iran and Israel over some bullshit. If one nuclear power wars with another the nukes will drop instantly. Stop trying to kill me, I don’t want to die in a nuclear blast for fucking Ukraine.

    intensely_human ,

    I didn’t read that comment as implying war was easy or okay. How’d you get that impression?

    Diabolo96 , (edited )

    the NATO/EU/US may decide to become directly involved in the war

    After their involvement, I doubt they’d do nothing if some of their soldiers get shredded by a Russian bomb. Let’s imagine Russia is beaten and it’s on the brink of complet defeat. Do you really not expect them to send nuclear warheads everywhere before collapsing as an ultimate fuck you ? 10% of the warheads are enough to turn earth into a post apocalyptic wasteland.

    yogthos ,
    @yogthos@lemmy.ml avatar

    Same goes the other way around, and given that Russia is in a stronger position than the west, that’s the scenario we should really be talking about. What happens when NATO gets shredded by Russia the same way their Ukrainian proxy. Will NATO just pack up and go home or escalate to use of nuclear weapons. Incidentally, US intentionally keeps an open posture on this.

    Diabolo96 ,

    Russia used to be that powerful, but not today. It will put a decent fight but I doubt it’ll be able to deal against so many powerful military foes.

    yogthos ,
    @yogthos@lemmy.ml avatar

    people who actually have a clue seem to disagree with you champ rusi.org/…/attritional-art-war-lessons-russian-wa…

    Harbinger01173430 ,

    We have 122 vaults spread all over, just in case, no? … No?

    lens17 , (edited )

    I’m by no means an expert in international relations. However, with respect to your last paragraph, I do think that China monitors the development carefully. I would even go so far and assume that they won’t act on Taiwan until the situation in the Ukraine is decided. Not because the cases are so similar, but because China and Russia seem to be important partners for each other. Right now, China is supporting Russia financially by buying resources from them (if I’m not mistaken) and also supporting them with equipment embargoed by the EU/US. China will probably know what it’s risking when they attack Taiwan and I doubt that they want to create that sort of situation while one of their most important partners (might be mistaken here) is in a war that binds their resources and weakens their support for China.

    On the other hand, they could also try to start the war on Taiwan soon, hoping that NATO/US stretch their support too thin.

    Tl;Dr: I don’t know either.

    intensely_human ,

    The number of fronts in this war seems to keep expanding.

    I hate that I predicted this all the way back when the “two week” lockdown was starting, and that nobody listened to me and I got accused of “valuing the economy over Grandma”.

    If my account hadn’t been deleted I could link to my comment where I predicted:

    • lockdowns would extend far longer than two weeks
    • it would ruin the global economy
    • causing world war 3 to start

    I was just laughed at basically.

    lens17 ,

    I can’t follow you. Where is the connection between lockdowns (I assume you mean the Covid19 lockdowns?) and the war in Ukraine?

    milicent_bystandr ,

    I’m jumping in after skimming so much long discussion… But I do see a possible link here. COVID and the lockdowns have shaken up a lot of society. I remember even back when the anti-mask and BLM protests happened in America about the same time (I’m not American btw, just seeing some news) feeling like the stress and shut-in-ness of lockdowns and COVID fear is probably part of the fuel for people to protest: it gives a sort of release from that.

    Now the economy’s been shaken up so much, and more people are finding it hard to get an acceptable job. The comfortable life trajectory many people were on has taken a hit and wealth they assumed was safe and assured (including things like house-buying prospects) has crumbled beneath them.

    Many are also suffering brain fog and Long COVID, making life feel less stable, and hitting their job prospects.

    The intensity of COVID responses also seems to have given much fuel to American political disunity, and hatred and resentment, as well as political/civil frustration elsewhere in the world.

    I don’t know how Russia has been, but I imagine there’s some of the same, at least. And all this unsettling of life and intangible worry, puts people in a much readier situation to rise up around some flash point - such as a war - or to be desperate enough to concede whatever demands their government makes of them - such as conscription for dubious end.

    Not that that’s the whole picture by any means, but, perhaps, there is some link from lockdowns to global war.

    gun ,
    @gun@lemmy.ml avatar

    Russia can then ingest Ukraine, continue to seed political distrust in Western countries and then potentially start another war in Europe a few years later.

    Holy shit this is the most mapgame-brained comment of all time. You mean Russia will get enough war score to annex Ukrainian territories, wait a few years for aggressive expansion to die down, spend some admin points to press the “sow discontent” button, then war when the casus belli is ready? Like a classic EU4 blob?

    Stop gaming and read some books.

    azulavoir ,

    I mean.

    It’s not like Russia has never done any of those things individually.

    So doing them again in that sequence seems right.

    OrnluWolfjarl ,

    It’s not like Russia has never done any of those things individually.

    [citation needed]

    bennieandthez ,
    @bennieandthez@lemmygrad.ml avatar

    Things are not getting objectively worse in the West, its just russian propaganda!

    jahashar ,

    Russia has been seeding discontent in Europe for decades. (1)

    Russia has invaded Checnya, Abkhazia, Southern Ossetia, Transnistria, Krim, Ukraine (2). Baltics stand next in line, in a few years, if West fails.

    It’s literally a sick war game for Putin’s Kreml.

    1. www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-68685604
    2. …m.wikipedia.org/…/List_of_wars_involving_Russia
    highalectical ,
    @highalectical@lemmygrad.ml avatar

    Baltics stand next in line, in a few years, if West fails.

    God, I hope so. The Baltics are fash af.

    gun ,
    @gun@lemmy.ml avatar

    Ok, I’ll bite

    1. How has Russia invaded Transnistria? Transnistria was a breakaway region during the collapse of the Soviet union, similar to Gagauzia
    2. No one disputes that Chechnya is Russian territory. Russia cannot invade its own territory.
    3. Georgian military intended to genocide ethnic minorities. Russia supported the autonomy of said minorities.
    4. Crimea was given to Ukraine by Kruschev very recently. It is almost entirely ethnically Russian, and those ethnic Russians voted overwhelmingly to secede during a coup/constitutional crisis as the alternative was staying in a country where there culture and language are banned, or worse become the target of hate crimes from neo-nazi battalions as many cases are well-documented
  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • random
  • [email protected]
  • tech
  • kbinEarth
  • testing
  • interstellar
  • wanderlust
  • All magazines